top of page

ThinkWicker

The Running Meter

Writer: Marcus Hale
Marcus Hale
12 minutes ago
6 min read

The unit a business prices in decides what its clients watch, and a price that counts every hour or every use teaches clients to judge the work by consumption instead of results.


The billable hour was never meant to be a price. Reginald Heber Smith, the lawyer usually credited with inventing it, became counsel of the Boston Legal Aid Society in 1913 and ran it on a thin budget by tracking each lawyer's hours on each matter. As managing partner of Hale and Dorr from 1919, he introduced the timesheet around 1920. Time was a management tool for knowing where effort went. Decades later, the same unit became what clients paid for, and every client began to watch a running meter.


The paradox is that both sides got what they asked for. Clients wanted to see what they were buying, and hours made the work visible. Firms wanted a defensible way to charge, and hours gave them one. The result was a relationship in which the buyer audits effort and the seller is rewarded for spending more of it.


Most pricing discussions focus on the level of the price. The more consequential choice is the unit, because the unit decides what the client looks at every time an invoice arrives.



How an internal metric became the price


James W. Jones, writing for the Thomson Reuters Institute in 2025, traces the billable hour's rise as the standard price unit to the 1970s and the rapid growth of corporate in-house legal departments. Their general counsel embraced hourly billing because they believed it showed what outside firms were doing for the money.


In 1975, the Supreme Court's decision in Goldfarb v. Virginia State Bar held that a minimum fee schedule published by a county bar association and enforced by the state bar violated the Sherman Act, which undercut the old way of pricing legal work.


WilmerHale's own history of Smith makes the original purpose clear. At first, it says, "the timesheet remained a purely internal metric, used for organizational planning and budgeting." Only later did Smith come to see it as a way to value legal services. Nobody set out to make clients evaluate legal advice by the tenth of an hour.


The unit a firm prices in becomes the unit its clients use to judge the work.

That shift matters well beyond law. Agencies, consultancies, architects, accountants and IT firms inherited the same unit, and with it the same habit of mind on the client side. When the invoice lists hours, the natural question in the client's review becomes whether the hours were justified, and the result recedes behind the count.



What flat-rate customers reveal


A study by Anja Lambrecht and Bernd Skiera, published in the Journal of Marketing Research in 2006, looked at the same question from the buyer's side. Using billing records for 10,882 customers of a European internet service provider over a period of up to five months, plus a survey of 1,078 of its customers, they compared the tariff each customer chose with the tariff that would have cost that customer the least.


Two findings stand out. Overpaying for a flat rate was far more common than the opposite mistake. Depending on the tariff and the test applied, up to 46.4 percent of customers in the five-month data had a flat-rate bias, against at most 5.8 percent with a pay-per-use bias, and the flat-rate bias was the more persistent of the two. More than half of the flat-rate-biased customers paid at least twice what their cheapest tariff would have cost.


Yet those customers did not have a significantly higher probability of canceling. The opposite mistake behaved very differently: customers on a pay-per-use plan who would have saved money on a flat rate had monthly churn 340 to 1,040 percent higher than customers on their cheapest tariff.


The authors explain the flat-rate bias mainly with two effects. An insurance effect: a flat fee lets customers avoid variation in their monthly bill. A taxi-meter effect: customers enjoy using the service more on a flat rate than when a charge rises with every use. Both effects made a flat-rate choice more likely.


Internet access is a long way from professional services, and the study did not test advisory work. Applying it to service firms is Wickersham's inference. What it suggests is that buyers value predictability for its own sake, and that a visible meter carries a cost for the buyer that never appears on the invoice.



The running meter, in three parts


The running meter describes any price unit that makes the buyer watch consumption. It shapes a client relationship through three parts.


  • Scrutiny. The unit sets what the client inspects. Hours invite an audit of effort. A fixed fee for a defined scope invites an assessment of the outcome.

  • Exposure. The unit decides who carries the risk of the unexpected. Per-unit pricing leaves it with the client, so every surprise in the work becomes a surprise on the bill.

  • Timing. The unit decides when value is felt. A meter charges during the work, while the benefit arrives later, so the client feels the cost before the result.


The three parts interact. High exposure makes scrutiny sharper, because a client who carries the risk has every reason to check the count. Poor timing makes exposure feel worse, because the client pays before seeing anything to set against the cost. A firm can do excellent work and still lose the relationship, because the meter kept the client's attention on the wrong number.


A visible meter carries a cost for the buyer that never appears on the invoice.


Where the running meter shows up


The pattern appears anywhere a service is priced per unit of input.


  • Overage clauses. A retainer with a cap and hourly overage reinstalls the meter at exactly the moment the client is most stretched.

  • Change orders. In construction and software, every scope change becomes a fresh negotiation, and the client learns to treat the vendor's flexibility as a cost center.

  • Usage-based software. Per-seat or per-call pricing can push customers to ration use of the product they bought, which weakens the habit that would renew it.

  • Reporting. Many retained firms report activity, such as posts, hours and meetings, because activity is what the old unit trained everyone to count.


The last one is easy to miss. Even a firm that has moved to a fixed fee can rebuild the meter in its monthly report. If the report leads with hours spent and deliverables shipped, the client keeps reading consumption.



The measurement problem


The cost of a running meter is hard to see because it shows up as behavior the firm never records. Clients ask for fewer calls than they need. They hold back a question because the answer will be billed. They delay starting a project until the budget feels safe. None of these appear in revenue reports, and all of them reduce the value the client receives.


Three questions bring the cost into view.


  1. What does the client inspect first? Look at the questions asked in invoice reviews. Questions about hours mean the meter is running.

  2. Where do surprises land? List the last five unexpected developments in client work and note who paid for each.

  3. When does the client first see value? Compare the date of the first invoice with the date of the first result the client would name.


Lambrecht and Skiera's churn pattern suggests one more signal. In their data, the customers who left at high rates were the ones paying by use when a flat rate would have been cheaper, while customers who overpaid for predictability did not leave at a significantly higher rate.


What this suggests for service firms is that clients exposed to the meter may be a larger retention risk than clients who feel they pay a premium. Firms tend to worry about the second group and overlook the first.



The decision the running meter puts in front of leaders


Every service firm prices in some unit, and none of the units are neutral. Hours, deliverables, phases, outcomes and fixed periods each point the client's attention somewhere different. A firm that wants to be judged by results has to stop handing clients a unit that measures effort.


Changing the unit carries real work. Scope has to be defined well enough that the firm can carry the exposure. Reporting has to describe progress toward the result rather than the count of activity. Some clients, especially those whose own governance requires an hourly audit trail, will prefer the meter, and their preference deserves respect.


The decision is which number you want your client looking at when your invoice arrives. Choose that number first, then build the unit around it.


Choose the number you want your client looking at, then build the price around it.


References



Some ideas are worth discussing in the context of your organization.



 
 

Need more than insights?

bottom of page