top of page

ThinkWicker

Your Brand Signal Is Worth What It Costs to Fake

Writer: Dana Voss
Dana Voss
9 hours ago
5 min read
Close-up of beige check fabric crossed by black, white and red stripes.
Photo by Yvette S

A brand signal keeps its meaning only while it is costly to display, so every license, discount channel and co-brand that makes it cheaper to show changes what the signal says.


A licensing partner calls with an offer. They will put the company's mark, its most recognizable brand signal, on a new product line, in a new market, at no cost to the company, and the royalty is small but steady. Nobody on the leadership team can name a downside, so the deal is signed within the quarter.


Two years later, there are a dozen deals like it, and the mark is on more products, in more stores, in front of more people than ever. Awareness is up. Then the brand starts to feel cheaper to the customers who used to pay the most for it, and nobody can say when it happened.


The usual diagnosis is a creative problem: the identity has gone stale and needs a refresh. That diagnosis is nearly always wrong, because the brand signal did not wear out. It got cheap to display, and a signal that anyone can display stops saying anything about the brand. It starts saying something about whoever is displaying it.



What a brand signal is worth


Economists have a precise way to describe this. In a 1973 paper in the Quarterly Journal of Economics, Michael Spence showed that a signal carries information only when it costs more for some people to send it than for others. An education credential tells an employer something because it is costly to earn. If the credential could be printed at home, it would tell the employer nothing.


A brand signal works the same way. A distinctive pattern, a mark, a material or a price point means "this is the real thing" only while it is hard for anyone else to show it. The meaning comes from the cost of display. Once the cost falls, the market keeps reading the signal, but it reads it differently. It looks past the brand to the people carrying it, and draws its conclusions from them.


A brand signal is worth exactly what it costs someone to fake it.


What happened to the Burberry check


Burberry is the clearest case on record. Its beige, black and red check had been a lining for the company's rainwear since the 1920s. By the early 2000s it was everywhere.


Angela Ahrendts, who became chief executive in 2006, described what she inherited in Harvard Business Review in 2013. Each of the company's 23 licensees worldwide was doing something different. The brand reached products far from its core; as The Globe and Mail put it, "Customers could even cover their lapdogs in Burberry." Each license made business sense on its own terms. Together, they made the check easy and cheap to own.


Counterfeiters made it cheaper still. Marketing Week reported in 2004 that the obvious branding had made it easy for counterfeiters to copy the check on a grand scale, and the pattern turned into British shorthand for the "chav" stereotype. Fashion writers still trace that association to 2002, when the actress Danniella Westbrook was photographed with her baby, both dressed in the check.


None of this was a design failure, and the pattern was as good as it had always been. What changed was who could display it, and at what cost. The check had gone from signaling an outerwear house founded in 1856 to signaling the people the tabloids were mocking.



The recovery was a governance decision


The fix was mostly structural. In her first years, The Globe and Mail reports, Burberry bought back 23 licenses, and she brought design under one global design director, Christopher Bailey. In the HBR article, she recalls the rule she gave her team: anything the consumer sees, anywhere in the world, would go through his office, with no exceptions. The check stayed, and Burberry stopped making the check caps most tied to the stereotype.


Burberry kept the signal and made it expensive to display again by controlling who could put it on a product, what that product had to be, and where it could be sold.



Three errors that lower the cost of a brand signal


Most companies never face counterfeiters at Burberry's scale. They make the same trade in quieter ways, through decisions that appear to be growth.


01. Licensing for reach. A license puts the mark in front of new people at little cost. It also hands the signal to a partner whose standards, products and customers the company does not choose. Each deal is small, but all of them share the signal, and the weakest partner sets what it means. A professional services firm that lets partners, affiliates or franchisees use its name without its standards is making the same trade.


02. Discount channels that carry the full mark. Outlets, marketplaces, deep promotions and bulk resellers lower the price of entry to the brand. Price is one of the main costs of display. When the cheapest place to buy the mark becomes the most visible place, the market reads the brand through its least expensive version.


03. Co-branding that borrows the signal. Partnerships, sponsorships and "powered by" arrangements allow other organizations to place the mark next to theirs. The partner gains credibility, while the brand is associated with every partner it lends itself to, including those that later disappoint customers or make the news for the wrong reasons.


Each of these errors appears in reports as a success. Licensing revenue rises, distribution widens, and awareness grows. The cost appears in a place most dashboards do not measure: what people now assume about someone who displays the brand.



How the brand signal differs from logo volume


We have written about logo volume, the question of how loudly a brand displays its own mark. This is a different decision. Logo volume is about the brand's own restraint. Display cost is about who else gets to carry the signal, and how cheaply. A brand can show its mark quietly and still lose control of it, if licensees, discounters and partners show it loudly on its behalf.


Decision

Logo volume asks

Display cost asks

Who controls it?

The brand itself

Licensees, channels, partners and counterfeiters

What goes wrong?

The mark is too loud

The mark becomes too cheap to display

What does the market read?

The brand’s confidence

The people carrying the brand



The first decision


Leaders usually start with the identity: refresh the mark, update the pattern, change the campaign. That work changes how the signal looks. It does nothing about how cheaply it can be shown.


The first decision is who may display the signal, and what it should cost them to do so. That means a list of every license, channel, partner and co-brand that carries the mark, with one question asked of each: does this arrangement raise or lower the cost of displaying the brand? If the answer is lower, the arrangement needs a standard, a limit or an exit before any design work begins.


The market reads a brand through the people who carry it, so the first brand decision is who gets to carry it.


References



Some ideas are worth discussing in the context of your organization.



 
 

Need more than insights?

bottom of page