top of page

ThinkWicker

Cued Word of Mouth

Writer: Soren Aldridge
Soren Aldridge
11 minutes ago
6 min read

Interesting products get talked about once; products that something in the customer's week keeps bringing to mind get talked about again and again.


Most advice about word of mouth starts from the same assumption: people talk about what is remarkable. Make the product surprising, the service unusual, the campaign clever, and customers will carry the message for you. Budgets for launches, stunts and "talkable" features rest on that idea.


Jonah Berger and Eric Schwartz tested it, and published the results in the Journal of Marketing Research in 2011. Their data showed that being interesting buys a short burst of conversation. What keeps a product in conversation over time is something more ordinary: how often the surrounding world reminds people of it. This piece calls that cued word of mouth.



What was studied


The paper combines a large field dataset with two experiments.


  • Campaign data. The authors worked with BzzAgent, a word-of-mouth marketing firm that sent products to volunteer "agents" and asked them to report the conversations they had about each one. The dataset covered 335 campaigns for more than 300 products, run between August 2002 and January 2009. The authors drew a sample of 2,000 agents, which gave nearly 11,000 agent-in-campaign observations. Each report counted as one conversation.

  • Product ratings. 109 independent coders scored the products on five-point scales: how interesting each one was, how publicly visible it was, and how frequently the surrounding environment might remind people of it.

  • Two time horizons. The authors separated immediate word of mouth, the first three weeks of a campaign, from ongoing word of mouth, the remainder, typically about seven more weeks. The results held when the cut point was moved to 2 or 4 weeks.

  • A field experiment. In a Boston Market campaign, 1,687 agents each received three emails. Half received messages linking the restaurant chain to dinner, a cue people meet every day. The other half received control messages. Before the campaign, agents rated how strongly they agreed with the statement "Boston Market is a dinner place" on a seven-point scale.

  • A lab study. 120 participants sat in pairs while the experimenter left the room for about ten minutes, and a laptop recorded their conversation. The researchers varied whether products were in view, whether related topics had been brought to mind, and whether an item had tested as more or less interesting.



What was found


The three product traits behaved differently across the two time horizons.


  • Interesting products received more immediate word-of-mouth (β = .06, t = 2.67). They did not receive more ongoing word-of-mouth, and across the whole campaign, interest had no significant effect.

  • Publicly visible products received more word-of-mouth in both periods (β = .14 for immediate, β = .06 for ongoing). A product one standard deviation above the mean on visibility got about 8% more word of mouth overall.

  • Products cued more often by the environment received more word-of-mouth in both periods (β = .05 immediate; β = .06 ongoing). A product one standard deviation above the mean on cues got about 15% more word of mouth overall.


The field experiment pointed the same way. The dinner messages raised word of mouth by 20% among agents who did not already link Boston Market with dinner. Among agents who already made that link, the messages had no significant effect. The messages also did not make the brand seem more interesting or novel.


The lab study matched both patterns. Products in view came up in 19% of conversations, against 2% when they were out of sight. Cued topics came up in 22% of conversations, against 4% when uncued. The more interesting items were discussed about as often as the less interesting ones, 13% against 11%.


Being interesting buys a product one round of conversation. Being cued buys it the rounds that follow.


Why it happens


The authors explain the pattern in terms of accessibility. In their account, everyday conversation is rarely planned. It often consists of "idle chatter about whatever happens to come to mind, regardless of how mundane it may be." People talk about whatever is at the front of their minds when a conversation happens, and the environment shapes much of what is there.


An interesting product earns a moment of attention, and the authors note that interest fades as people learn more about a product. Once the novelty passes, nothing in the person's day brings it back, so it drops out of conversation. A product tied to a frequent cue keeps returning to mind each time the cue appears, giving it new opportunities to be mentioned. Public visibility works similarly because seeing other people use the product is itself a cue.


The mechanism matters because it shifts word of mouth from the product to the customer's surroundings. Two products of equal quality and appeal can end up with very different levels of conversation simply because one sits next to something people encounter every day and the other does not. A marketing team looking only at the product itself would never see the difference, since the cause lives in the calendar, the commute and the kitchen rather than in the offer.


The authors set this against a motivational account. Most people want others to think highly of them, and talking about interesting things serves that goal. The authors conclude that ongoing word of mouth, in particular, is driven by accessibility rather than by a desire to seem interesting. That motive helps in the first conversation. It does little to create the second.



The limits of the evidence


The study is strong on scale and design, and it has clear boundaries.


  • Everyday consumer products dominate. Packaged food, books, household products and personal care made up about 61% of campaigns. Financial services were 2% and restaurants 2%. Professional services and large, considered purchases were barely represented.

  • The agents were volunteers in a marketing program. They knew they were expected to talk and to report. Their conversations may differ in volume, though perhaps less in pattern, from those of ordinary customers.

  • Self-reported conversations from one firm. The data are agents' own reports, which the authors acknowledge could be exaggerated or incomplete. The conversations were mostly face-to-face, and the authors flag online word of mouth as needing separate study.

  • The ratings are judgments. Each coder rated a different set of 50 products, so agreement among them could not be calculated directly. Separate research assistants who coded the full set reached reliability above .79.


Everything below about business-to-business firms and professional services is Wickersham's inference. The study did not test those settings.



What cues word of mouth changes for brands


What this suggests is that the usual question about word of mouth points at the wrong trait. Organizations ask how remarkable they are. The study suggests asking what in the customer's ordinary week comes to mind.


This is a different idea from treating referrals as a measure of brand strength, which ThinkWicker has argued before. A referral count indicates how many people have recommended a firm. Cued word-of-mouth explains why some of those people keep recommending it months later, while others mention it once and stop.


For a firm that grows by referral, the inference runs as follows.


  1. Find the recurring moment. Budget season, the monthly board meeting, quarter close, a payroll run, the first cold week of the year. These are the moments when a client's colleagues ask each other for advice.

  2. Tie the brand to that moment on purpose. The tie can be a product feature, a regular report that arrives at that moment, or a phrase clients start to use for it.

  3. Prefer frequent cues over dramatic ones. A cue that appears every week offers more chances to be mentioned than one that appears once a year, even if the annual one is more memorable.


The same logic applies to health centers that rely on patients to tell friends and family. A flu clinic remembered as interesting may be mentioned once. A clinic linked to the start of the school year, or to the moment a parent fills out a sports physical form, has a recurring reason to come up.


The question for a referral-driven firm is what in the client's week will put the firm back in mind.

None of this makes novelty worthless. Interesting work still earns the first round of conversation, and a brand needs that round to be known at all. The study suggests that novelty and cues do different jobs, and that most marketing plans fund the first and leave the second to chance.


The research cannot tell a professional services firm which cue will work for its clients. It does sharpen the question. Asking how remarkable the work is measures the first conversation. Asking which ordinary moment in a client's week will bring the firm to mind, and how often that moment comes around, measures the ones that follow.



References



Some ideas are worth discussing in the context of your organization.



 
 

Need more than insights?

bottom of page